Strategy Shares Slide as Analyst Warns of More Losses, Saylor Defends Buybacks

By Aaron Feuerstein November 20, 2026 In Microstrategy, Stock Market
strategy b fall of shares
  • Strategy shares fell 4.64% to US$86.13 after Monness, Crespi, Hardt downgraded MSTR to sell, setting a US$65 price target amid Bitcoin weakness.
  • Strategy repurchased US$228.1 million in STRC preferred shares, largely funded through ordinary share sales, raising concerns about further shareholder dilution.
  • Michael Saylor defended the buybacks as a way to reduce dividend obligations, while Peter Schiff questioned their sustainability and potential impact on shareholders.
  • Strategy’s 850,849 BTC holdings are worth approximately US$11.9 billion less than their acquisition cost, although several major brokerages retain buy ratings on MSTR.

After a previous close of US$90.32 (AU$135.51), Strategy (MSTR) shares have slipped another 4.64% and are down to US$86.13 (AU$129.22). This comes as analysts are starting to take note of the company’s exposure to Bitcoin and the weak price performance of the digital asset.

Monness, Crespi, Hardt & Co. has downgraded its rating for MSTR from neutral to sell with a price target of US$65 (AU$97.52), implying another 24.5% downside. Bitcoin’s decline puts pressure on the company’s valuation.

Analyst Gus Galá also pointed to Strategy’s leverage and the possibility of further shareholder dilution. He believes investors may become less willing to pay extra for the company’s Bitcoin-per-share growth if it continues issuing ordinary shares to fund preferred-share dividends and repurchases.

Strategy Defends Share Buybacks

According to its latest filing, Strategy repurchased US$228.1 million (AU$342.2 million) worth of STRC preferred shares between 9 and 15 November. Of that amount, US$206.3 million (AU$309.5 million) was funded through MSTR share sales.

Advertisement

However, Strategy executive chairman Michael Saylor defended the approach in a post on X on 19 November.

Related: Bitcoin Shows Signs of a Bottom After Six Weekly Losses, But ETF Outflows Continue

He highlighted that STRC had recorded more than US$600 million (AU$900 million) in trading volume the previous day, making it the only one of 456 US-listed income preferred securities to reach that level this year.

Saylor said Strategy intends to continue buying STRC below US$100 (AU$150), arguing that the repurchases reduce dividend obligations and benefit ordinary shareholders.

But long-time Bitcoin critic Peter Schiff challenged Saylor’s argument. Schiff questioned why Saylor was celebrating STRC’s high trading volume and asked how Strategy would continue funding its repurchases if it ran short of cash.

He raised the possibility of further shareholder dilution or Bitcoin sales to finance the buybacks.

Advertisement

With STRC currently carrying a 12% annual dividend rate, the recent repurchases could reduce Strategy’s annual dividend obligations by approximately US$27.4 million (AU$41.1 million), assuming the rate remains unchanged.

However, issuing additional ordinary shares to finance those purchases also increases the number of shares outstanding.

Analysts Remain Divided

While other analysts have reduced their price targets, most major brokerages continue to recommend buying the stock.

B. Riley maintained a buy rating with a US$180 (AU$270) target, while Cantor Fitzgerald and Maxim Group have targets of US$208 (AU$312) and US$215 (AU$322.50), respectively.

Year-on-year, MSTR’s price is down 51%, while Bitcoin has dropped 33% and currently trades for US$61,459 (AU$92,226).

Strategy held 850,849 BTC as of 15 November, acquired at an average price of US$75,452 (AU$113,178) per coin. At current prices, those holdings are worth approximately US$11.9 billion (AU$17.9 billion) less than the company originally paid.

The question is whether Strategy’s approach to managing its financial obligations will ultimately benefit ordinary shareholders or whether further dilution and continued Bitcoin weakness will put additional pressure on MSTR.

Read also: Hackers Compromise 178 Websites in Attempt to Steal Crypto

Aaron Feuerstein
Author

Aaron Feuerstein

Aaron Feuerstein is a freelance writer based in Melbourne. His focus is on decentralised finance and the regulatory space surrounding blockchain. He holds a Master's in Accounting. When he is not studying the latest legal case, he enjoys his time as a modest but eager hobby cook.

You may also like