Germany Moves Towards Allowing Crypto Freezes Without Criminal Charges
- The Bundestag passed the Customs and Financial Fairness Act on 12 November with votes from the CDU/CSU, SPD and AfD.
- Customs could hold crypto and other assets worth over €100,000 for 30 days, extendable once by 150 days, when there are signs they were not lawfully obtained.
- The bill needs Bundesrat consent, and permanent confiscation would require a finance court ruling unless the owner admits unlawful origin.
Germany’s Bundestag voted on 12 November to let customs officers freeze crypto and other assets worth more than €100,000 (Around US$110,072 or AU$163,409) when their lawful origin is in doubt, without first opening a criminal case.
The governing CDU/CSU and SPD backed the bill, joined by the far-right AfD, according to the Bundestag’s record of the vote. The Left voted against the bill, and the Greens abstained.
The measure still needs the consent of the Bundesrat, the upper house. It is not on the agenda for the chamber’s next sitting on 20 November. If the Bundesrat consents, most of the law takes effect on 1 January 2027.
The bill, called the “Zollfinanzgerechtigkeitsgesetz”, creates an administrative procedure for cases where suspicion falls short of what a criminal investigation requires. Criminal proceedings still take precedence where they apply.
Saxony investigators took that route when they secured almost 50,000 BTC in January 2024 in a piracy case.
The new procedure covers assets customs finds in the course of its work. Those include crypto-assets as defined under the EU’s MiCA crypto rulebook.
Customs can hold such an asset for up to 30 days when there are factual indications it was not lawfully obtained. A finance court can extend that period once, by 150 days.
The owner is asked for documents showing where the assets came from, but must be told there is no duty to provide them. Any documents handed over can be used in tax and criminal proceedings.
Read more: Strategy And Metaplanet Removed from MSCI Indexes, Risking Billions in Passive Fund Outflows
Court Decides on Confiscation
Permanent confiscation needs a ruling from a finance court, which must be convinced the assets are not of lawful origin. Customs can skip the court if the owner admits the assets came from unlawful sources. A finance committee amendment on 11 November handed that ruling to a panel of judges.
The government argues that almost every law-abiding citizen can show where assets above the €100,000 threshold came from. The Bundesrat asked in September for a full reversal of the burden of proof onto owners. The government refused, saying a further shift would not secure the full conviction of the court that the constitution requires.
SPD MP Ingo Vogel told the chamber: “Criminally acquired assets enjoy no constitutional protection of fundamental rights under Article 14.”
The Federal Bar, BRAK, rejects the bill’s overall concept and calls the term unlawful origin too vague. It says missing paperwork for assets inherited over generations must not count as evidence of illegal origin. The German Bar Association, DAV, also opposes the bill.
The government expects the law to raise about US$339 million (AU$503.3 million) a year in extra revenue from 2028. Greens MP Max Lucks set that against the roughly US$110 billion (AU$163.3 billion) he said is laundered in Germany each year.